Skip to content

And Then We Were No More – September 19-November 2

September 19 – November 2, 2025

Ellen Stewart Theatre
66 East 4th Street
New York, NY 10003

*Tickets:

$49 Weeknights & Matinees
$99 Friday & Saturday evenings
$10 first ten tickets to each performance (limit 2 per person)
$10 La MaMa Members (during previews 9/19-9/27)

Ticket prices are inclusive of all fees.
All seating is general admission.

A play by Tim Blake Nelson

Directed by Mark Wing-Davey

ABOUT

How do you plead for justice in a world that no longer believes in mercy?
 
A searing and provocative world premiere by actor/writer Tim Blake Nelson, directed by Mark Wing-Davey.
 
In the not-too-distant future a lawyer is forced to represent a prisoner deemed ‘beyond rehabilitation’ and destined to perish in a newly developed machine designed to execute ‘without pain.’ The attorney must strive for justice in a system devoid of mercy.
 
The cast of And Then We Were No More features Elizabeth Marvel (Broadway: King Lear, Other Desert Cities; Long Day’s Journey Into Night; House Of Cards; Homeland), Scott Shepherd (Ulysses, Bridge of Spies), Jennifer Mogbock (Half God Of Rainfall; Merry Wives), Henry Stram (Titanic, The Elephant Man), Elizabeth Yeoman (Airtime; The Children’s Hour), William Appiah (Fences; Hamlet), E.J. An (A Dream of Red Pavilions; Clubhouse), Kasey Connolly (Four Women Entering Paradise; FBI), and Craig Wesley Divino (London Assurance; Round Table).

STOP THE WIND THEATRICALS

STOP THE WIND THEATRICALS is a new producing model that provides a page to stage framework for developing authentic and audacious new plays and provides the resources necessary for artists at each stage of the process. We nurture, connect and cultivate always with the goal of moving plays toward production. Whether experimental or commercial, from the head or from the heart, we understand how good theater works. Producer Carol Ostrow has 30 years of producing experience – classical or avant-garde, devised or structured, ensemble or solo –  with networks that are local, national, and global. Stop The Wind was created to propel the widest range of theatrical possibility. Current projects include And Then We Were No More by Tim Blake Nelson, A Trojan Woman by Sara Farrington, Pierre by Keith Reddin, Jackals by Adam Rapp, Words We Believe by Rehana Lew Mirza, and Ann Fran and Maryann by Erin Courtney.

 

CREDITS

Producer: Carol Ostrow
Playwright: Tim Blake Nelson
Assistant to the Playwright: Hannah Blake
Director: Mark Wing-Davey
Assistant to the Director: Ali Skamangas
Stage Manager: Leo Nobiletti
Assistant Stage Manager: Claire Alderfer
Production Manager: Erica Schnitzer
Scenic Designer: David Meyer
Assistant to the Scenic Designer: Josh Barilla
Property Designer: Patricia Marjorie
Costume Designer: Marina Draghici
Assistant to the Costume Designer: Hanxiao Zhang
Lighting Designer: Reza Behjat
Assistant to the Lighting Designer: Kaia Merrell
Composer and Sound Designer: Henry Nelson
Fight Director: Mark Olsen

*Why Some Tickets Cost More (and How That Helps Everyone)

We offer higher-priced tickets at select performances (Friday and Saturday evenings for AND THEN WE WERE NO MORE). These higher-priced tickets help underwrite lower-priced tickets on other nights, making theater more accessible to everyone.

In short, when you pay a little more at certain performances, you’re not just seeing a show—you’re helping us keep ticket prices affordable for others and supporting year-round programming, artist development, and community engagement.

It’s one ticket, but it goes a long way.

A black background with a black square.

La Mama is a world-renowned New York cultural institution dedicated to the artist and all aspects of the theatre.