"Dora," a new two-hour,
two-act opera for nine singers and chamber orchestra by Melissa Shiflett (music)
and Nancy Fales Garrett (libretto), is an imaginative recreation of one of Freud's
best-known cases. It is based on "A Fragment of an Analysis of a Case of
Hysteria" (1905), Freud's account of his failed analysis of a young girl,
Dora Bauer, and even uses some of Freud's own words. La MaMa E.T.C. will present
the world premiere of the work April 4 to 14 in its Annex Theater, directed by
librettist Nancy Fales Garrett and conducted by Douglas Anderson, Artistic Director
of American Chamber Opera Company.
In the fall of 1900, Dora's father, hoping the celebrated doctor could cure her
hysterical symptoms, brought her to Freud's Vienna consulting room. Freud listened
to Dora and her dreams and believed her when she complained that her father was
offering her as a sexual reward to his mistress' husband, Herr K. But he was
by no means sure; the case came at a turning point in Freud's career, when he
was abandoning his belief that childhood sexual abuse was the leading cause of
hysteria in his patients. A "great secret" was gradually dawning on
him: that their childhood seductions, upon which his theory of hysteria had been
based, were actually imaginings.
According to Freud, Dora
was in love with her father, with her father's mistress, with the mistress'
husband, and, quite possibly, with the analyst himself, so it was Dora's own
refusal or inability to acknowledge sexual desire which was making her ill.
After a short period of treatment, Dora broke off the analysis, leaving Freud
disappointed, angry, and not at all assured of her future mental integrity.
Modern interpreters have seen Dora as struggling with anti-Semitism and sexual
imperialism, neither of which she could recognize, and her story has been continually
troubling and fascinating to today's minds. The historical story is intact
in the opera, but the events subsequent to Dora's analysis are telescoped in
time and altered slightly, including the climactic scene in which the young
girl confronts the K's while they are mourning the drowning of their son. The
opera is both modern and lyrical, combining Shiflett's distinctly American
sound with turn-of-the-century Viennese elements (waltzes, Schrammelquartets,
gypsy tunes). Reviewing the 1991 concert version, the Brooklyn Journal (William
Everdell) cited it as an exciting combination of music and book with an exceedingly
powerful story (drawn partly from Freud's proud letter to Fleiss). The review
noted how the grand and ongoing revision of Freud's reputation--and psychoanalysis
in general--has turned the title character of this opera into a modern hero.
Yet Freud was "saved
from being taken as a villain" by a sensitive performance and by having
his own psychobiography brought on stage. The presence of Freud's daughter,
Anna, served to "ironize and deepen" his analysis of Dora. The action
of the play is not, primarily, the analysis, but the dramatically-drawn relationship
between Dora and her "seducers." The simple line, "Father, I
am your daughter," is sung in three different places by three different
characters, with Shiflett's music taking advantage of each repeat with complex
and powerful results. The part of Freud is written
for a tenor, since Herr Doktor's relationships with Dora and with his own daughter,
according to his own theory, were basically romantic--and the tenor is the
romantic voice. The product of twelve years'
development, "Dora" was selected by The New York City Opera for its
first annual Showcasing American Composers in 1999. Previous to that, a concert
version was sung at the West Kortright Center in East Meredith, NY in 1990
and at a benefit sponsored by St. Ann's School at the First Presbyterian Church
in Brooklyn Heights in 1991. In 1993, selections were sung in a workshop at
Theater 22 in 1993 as part of Golden Fleece, LTD's Square One series. When
the orchestration was completed in 1997, the American Chamber Opera Company
staged a workshop production at the Liederkranz Club in NYC. The initial research
in Vienna was funded by a NY State Foundation for the Arts fellowship received
by the playwright in 1989. This production was partially funded by a benefit
sponsored by the Foundation of the New York Freudian Society and by a grant
from the Aaron Copeland Fund for New Music.Composer Melissa Shiflett
has had operas produced by the Pennsylvania Opera Theatre, the Minnesota Opera
and the American Chamber Opera Company in New York City. Her art songs, "Songs
on Beauty, Death and Nature and Water Dreams," will be premiered at Weill
Recital Hall at Carnegie Hall by soprano Shauna Holiman, April 18th, 2002.
These songs are recorded for release this spring on Albany Records. Librettist/director
Nancy Fales Garrett is author of the plays "Playing in Local Bands" (National
Playwrights Conference, Eugene ONeill Theater Center, 1982; Yale Rep and Magic
Theatre, 1983) and "Some Sweet Day" (Long Wharf Theater, Main Stage,
1989), but nothing in her dramatic work before "Dora" remotely foreshadowed
this work, which has a distinctive character of its own, being a simultaneous
collaboration with composer Melissa Shiflett. Her three earliest plays were
presented by La MaMa, "How They Made It" (1969), "Predicates:
A Dance" (1970) and "ARK" (1974), a musical theater piece with
jazz compositions by Sonelius Smith. (She directed the second one.) She teaches
playwriting at St. Ann's School, Brooklyn and annually stages Shakespeare comedies
with teens for Shakespeare in the Valley in East Meredith, NY.Conductor Douglas
Anderson founded American Chamber Opera Company in 1984 and is its artistic
and administrative head. The company has presented over sixty productions,
primarily modern chamber operas, and has achieved an international reputation
for theatrical boldness and originality. Its productions have been featured
on local, national and international radio, including NPR, Pacifica and Voice
of America. With the Downtown Symphony, Anderson conducts four to five concerts
a season, including two orchestral concerts, an annual Messiah Sing-along (now
in its 13th year), a children's concert and an opera in concert outdoors. He
has composed chamber works, orchestral works, concerti, vocal music (including
synthesized voice), electronic music, radio drama, jazz, film scores, and musical
theater. Set design is by John Scheffler; lighting design is by Matthew Staniec;
costume design is by Kate Herman; video/slide projections are by Lisa Bloch.
Choreographer is Marcos Dinnerstein. THE CASTNita Baxani (Dora), soprano, was
born in Hong Kong, raised in Virginia and educated in New York City. She was
the featured soprano soloist with Moving Forward: Asian Contemporary Dance
Program at the Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts. Her roles have included
Pamina in "The Magic Flute," Antonia in "The Tales of Hoffman,"
Amore in "Orfeo ed Eurydice," Serafina in "Il Campanello",
Roberto in "La Griselda" and at La MaMa, Teenage Mao in "Mao
Zedong - Jealous Son." Jeffrey Picón (Freud),
tenor, most recently created the role of Mike in :A View from the Bridge"
for the Lyric Opera of Chicago. He debuted with Anchorage Opera as Jupiter in
Handel's "Semele" and Count Almaviva in "Il Barbiere di Siviglia"
with Portland Opera Repertory Theater. Other significant roles include Joe in
"Ballymore" for Skylight Opera Theatre, Vicente in David Bishop's
"Esperanza" in Madison, WI, and the American premiere of Alexander
Goehr's "Arianna" at the Opera Theatre of St. Louis, where he has
also sung Pedrillo in the "Die Entfuhrung aus dem Serail." Kathryn
Wright (Frau K), soprano, has appeared in recitals, operas and concerts with
over sixty orchestras, premiering works with the Kennedy Center, National Chamber
Orchestra and Chanctonbury Chorus, England, and singing lead roles with the
Metropolitan Opera Guild and Minnesota, Chautauqua, and Central City Operas.
She may be heard on Capstone Records. Peter Lurié (Herr
K), tenor, grew up in Johannesberg, South Africa and is also an architect.
He has appeared across the US and in Germany, Belgium, Great Britain, and
the Spoleto Festival in Charleston, SC. He will make his debut at the Royal
Belgian Opera, Brussels and the Rouen Opera in 2003. He sang Herr K in the
first Dora concert recital in 1990.Peter Clark (Herr Bauer),
baritone, has sung recently at the Teatro dell'opera di Roma in Krenek's "What
Price Confidence?", at Caramoor Opera in Verdi's "Otello" and
"Mozart's Die Zauberflute," and with the American Opera Company in
Puccini's "La Boheme." He appeared in Theodora Skipitares' "A
Harlot's Progress." A frequent recital partner of composer/pianist Christopher
Berg, he created the role of Iachimo in the NYC concert premiere of Berg's opera
based on Shakespeare's "Cymbeline." Johana Arnold (Frau Bauer),
mezzo soprano, originated the role of Dora in the premier concert recital of
the opera over ten years ago. She sings frequently with the Folger Consort
in Washington, DC both in concert works and in Baroque operas, including "Dido
and Aeneas," in which she sang the role of Dido. Ms Arnold has worked
with Steve Reich, Phil Glass, Meredith Monk and Mark Morris. She resides in
upstate New York and teaches at Hartwick College.Karla Simmons (Anna Freud),
soprano, is a graduate of the Julliard School who received her early training
from the New York City Opera Company and attended the High School of the Performing
Arts. She has given solo concerts in the New York area since the age of twelve
and has won the Leontyne Price, Lena Horne and Whitney Houston awards.Kayla
Ny (Zinnie K), soprano, is 13 and attends Manhattan School of Music Preparatory
Division where she studies music theory and voice. She has sung with numerous
choirs since she was eight and has performed on 4 CD's. Nate Morgan (Heinrich
K), boy soprano, played Young Scrooge in "The Christmas Carol" at Orpheus
Theatre in Oneonta, New York and Sr Angelica's Son in Puccini's "Sister
Angelica" at SUNY College Music Dept Oneonta. www.dora-the-opera.com
|